Clancy, Tom


****       The Hunt for Red October   Amazon
Fiction

Soviets and Americans chasing each other around in submarines and so forth, this is way better than the movie, and way better than Clancy's other books. He errs only a little in explaining too much (unlike his later work, which is full of "Gee, see what I learned yesterday?") In this book, there's lots of technostuff, but the presentation is comparatively seamless. One of the strengths is how well he makes the whole thing believable; his characters just seem real, like someone you know. Great story, spotty but decent writing.


*       Red Storm Rising   Amazon
Fiction

Didn't like it. Story is OK; Clancy still makes the characters seem real - you get sympathetic with a senior Soviet general, for example - but the overall effect doesn't work. Too much failed detail - he gives lots of detail you don't want or care about and all his strategies and tactical operations seem directly derived from board games.